Here’s the scenario: pre-books are high and the forecast is particularly strong this year. It’s looking like it’s going to be a good season. And of course nobody wants to tell a retailer that the item their customers keep asking for is out of stock in the middle of a hot season. So it can be tempting to bump up the numbers a bit for next season’s factory order.
But “a little extra” looks very different across a product line. Smaller products that tend to lend themselves to impulse buys or easy add-ons might fit on a shelf and sell steadily over the coming months. But the bulkier, big ticket items can take up considerable warehouse space while holding cash your team needs for the next production order.
On Between the Drops, Chris Vonderhaar, Director of Sales at Matador Equipment, and Nellie Stephenson, the brand’s Chief Operating Officer, talk through that distinction. The travel gear brand sells small accessories alongside larger packs, and those products carry very different risks when a forecast misses. Their experience shows why the same inventory cushion can be sensible for one product and expensive for another. Comparing the cost of carrying extra stock with the cost of catching up after a shortage helps brands decide where to buy deeper and when to ask retailers for firmer commitments.
Different products sell at different rates and require different approaches to replenishment.
As Nellie explains, “The approach is also sort of different depending on what the product is, right? Like a small accessory is very affordable… It’s cheap to airship if you’re under forecast, and just the cost of holding a lot of buffer inventory there doesn’t add up as fast as trying to hold buffer inventory of, you know, 26 different bags with a price point over $150 MSRP.”
That variable cost of carrying extra inventory across products gives brands a reason to look beyond a standard inventory buffer applied across the catalog. Adding the same percentage to every forecast may be easy to calculate, but it can leave you with more money committed to some products than you intended.
A warehouse full of product might look reassuring when you’re expecting strong sales. But if those sales take longer than planned, you could be sitting on inventory while you need that cash for something else.
Consider what buying “a little extra” means for your cash. A 10% buffer on a 3,000-unit forecast adds 300 extra units. At a $5 landed cost per accessory, that’s $1,500. At a $40 landed cost per pack, it’s $12,000 for a single style. The same buffer ties up eight times as much cash, before you account for storing those extra units.
“If I overbuy something, ultimately time is the ultimate solution, right? Like you adjust your forecasts, you adjust your purchases, it sells down eventually,” Nellie says. “But from the business side, yeah, you’ve got all this cash tied up and that’s not where we want to be.”
Put a dollar amount on the buffer before you commit, then consider what happens if those units take a few extra months to sell. Include storage costs and look at whether you’d still have enough cash to fund the next production run. Buying a little extra may be the right call, but you need to know how long you can afford to hold it.
Buying conservatively can leave your team with orders waiting and no stock available to fill them. Nellie points to air freight as one way Matador can respond when demand outpaces the forecast:
“When something’s doing really great, you can’t be that upset, right? We’ve got certain levers we can pull, like we can move things by air to try to shorten the supply chain and transportation leg.”
Before you count on that option, work out the full restocking timeline, including production time as well as transportation. Faster freight only helps once the goods are ready to move.
Then compare the added freight cost with the margin on the orders it would fill. Bringing in a smaller quantity by air might cover urgent retailer needs while the rest travels by your usual method. If the added cost eats up too much of that margin, waiting may make more sense.
Use that replenishment cost to guide the original buy, too. If catching up would mean an expensive air shipment, factor that expense into the risk of buying too little. If you can restock affordably while retailers still need the product, you may have more room to start with a smaller buffer.
When a product takes off, enthusiasm alone makes a shaky basis for the next factory order. Several accounts may say they want more, but their actual quantities could vary considerably by the time stock arrives.
Matador uses those moments to ask retailers to commit. When demand is high and inventory is low, the team encourages accounts to place orders to reserve incoming stock.
“When things are really overperforming and demand is high and stock is low, that's a really great opportunity for us to go to our retailers and be like, If you guys want to reserve some inventory, now is the time to put the order in.” Nellie explains. “We can go a little less blind if we've got commitments, especially from accounts that move much bigger volumes.”
Concrete orders give a firmer basis for replenishment, and they also help gauge demand for at-once purchasing once inventory becomes available again.
For brands facing a similar shortage, reps can make that conversation specific. Confirm how much an account wants and verify that the expected delivery timing works for the store. A retailer that needs product for an event next month may have little use for a shipment arriving after it ends.
Track committed orders separately from your estimate of additional demand. Otherwise, it’s easy to count the same retailer twice, first in the order book and again in a general projection. Commitments help reduce uncertainty, but you still need to decide how much uncommitted inventory to buy for later reorders.
When historical data is available, Matador uses it to guide forecasting. But what about a new line or product? That means making purchasing decisions before without the benefit as a sales history to work with.
A smart inventory forecasting process gives each product a demand estimate, but also a clear plan of action if sales move away from it. That plan should reflect the cost of being wrong in either direction.
Before placing a purchase order, work through a slower sales case alongside a stronger one. For the slower case, estimate how long the inventory would take to sell and whether you could afford to carry it that long. For the stronger case, identify when you would run short and what replenishment would cost.
Use those answers to set a review point. That could mean revisiting a new bag’s forecast after its opening orders, or reviewing an established accessory when available stock approaches its reorder point.The timing should leave your team room to act.
Adding “a little extra” to a factory order can help keep retailers supplied. But those extra units also commit money you may need elsewhere. If one product takes longer to sell than expected, you still need enough cash to reorder another that’s selling faster. A strong forecast is a reason to plan for more sales, but it’s worth checking how much room that plan leaves you if demand shifts.
Matador’s experience shows why that check belongs at the product level. Some extra inventory will be worth carrying; other purchases may need firmer retailer commitments before you increase the buy.
Before your next factory order, run each product through these five questions:
The products with the costliest answers, in either direction, deserve the closest look. The aim is to support the sales you expect while keeping enough cash available to respond to what actually happens. That way, today’s reassuring inventory cushion doesn’t become the reason you can’t fill tomorrow’s orders.
Want the full conversation? Listen to Chris and Nellie on Between the Drops here, or on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or Youtube.